On the flight back from a work trip last week I had time to watch all four episodes of the HBO documentary series 'Stax: Soulsville U.S.A.', which was originally broadcast last year.
It is definitely worth watching for the vintage clips of the performers and of the social context of the time like the Memphis sanitation strike and the King assassination. But as the series progressed I found myself getting a bit irritated, for two reasons.
The first was that proceedings became increasingly dominated by Al Bell, a man who appears to be a stranger to self-reflection. According to him he was the prime reason for the label's rise but bore absolutely no responsibility at all for its demise, being just a victim of circumstance and a racist plot.
To be fair he undoubtedly made a major contribution from the time he arrived as director of promotions in 1965 and later as co-owner and then sole owner. Arguably the label would not have survived Atlantic Records severing ties in 1968 and taking the whole back catalogue without him. It is also true that CBS treated Stax very shabbily after Mr Bell signed a distribution deal with them in 1972 shortly after becoming sole owner.
But at the time he took over Stax had just had chart-topping singles and albums from the likes of Jean Knight, Isaac Hayes and the Staple Singers and the studios were generating fees as a result of being hired by the likes of Elvis Presley. Yet they were bankrupt in under three years, and you have to suspect that some of the decisions Mr Bell took - such as trying to expand into the rock and pop markets - may have contributed.
The second irritation was all the artists who didn't get a look in. Quite rightly there was a lot of focus on the likes of Booker T & The MGs, Isaac Hayes, Otis Redding and Sam & Dave and the clips of them live on stage are fantastic (especially Sam & Dave).
They managed to fit in a clip featuring one of Mr Bell's late signings, the Scottish Queen of Soul herself, Lena Zavaroni (no disrespect intended to Lena, but possibly a sign that they had lost their way a bit by then). But somehow across the four hours that the series lasts they could not find room for the likes of Eddie Floyd, William Bell or even the mighty Staple Singers (which must be bordering on sacrilege).
In summary, its a good series but it could have been better still with a more balanced commentary and by including more of the many amazing artists on the label.
Here are some of those who did not make the cut, and one who did.
"Born Under A Bad Sign" - Albert King
"Big Bird" - Eddie Floyd
"Backfield In Motion" - Mel & Tim
"My Main Man" - The Staple Singers
"I'm Gonna Cry A River" - Little Milton
"I Forgot To Be Your Lover" - William Bell